Police chiefs hit back at watchdog over call for action on social media posts

7 May 2025, 00:04

Police response to summer riots examined
Police response to summer riots examined. Picture: PA

The National Police Chiefs’ Council said responsibility for the accuracy of posts lies with users, platforms and regulators.

Police chiefs have hit out at a watchdog report that called on forces to work faster to counter misleading social media posts such as those that fuelled last summer’s riots.

His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services called on social media companies, Ofcom and the police to take quicker action to tackle false information in times of disorder.

Head of the watchdog, Sir Andy Cooke, told journalists that misinformation and disinformation posted on social media helped fuel the disorder across England last summer, and misleading posts were left up too long.

He spoke to journalists as the watchdog’s second report on the policing response to the riots was published.

The report said forces had not heeded recommendations given by the inspectorate in 2011 and 2021 about intelligence relating to disorder, as well as dealing with social media.

Force chiefs need to be prepared to counter false information or a lack of information with the truth, Sir Andy said, and should consider how to be more open with journalists from established mainstream media outlets about all major investigations.

“Forces can’t control or counter the speed and volume of online content, that goes without saying, but they need to better appreciate how fast-moving events will require them to counter the false narratives online and be innovative in their approach,” he said.

“They need to fill the information void that we saw throughout this disorder that was filled with so much misinformation and disinformation, because that misinformation, disinformation, could go viral very, very quickly.

“So policing cannot be passive when public safety is at risk.”

Some forces have an “exceptionally limited” ability to deal with content online due to a lack of resources, the report said.

But the chairman of the National Police Chiefs’ Council, Gavin Stephens, said “a more balanced assessment” is needed.

He said: “While there are lessons to learn, it is crucial to acknowledge that law enforcement does not – and should not – regulate online content.

“Responsibility for ensuring information is accurate and does not fuel harm lies with those posting it, platform providers and regulatory bodies.”

The report included a comment from one force head of communications who told inspectors the police service had “no proper answer” for managing misinformation and disinformation.

Mr Stephens continued: “The report states that policing has ‘no proper answer’ for tackling misinformation and disinformation, but the issue extends far beyond law enforcement.

“No public sector organisation or body responsible for public safety is fully equipped to address the scale and complexity of the problem.

“Policing alone cannot be expected to lead or resolve this volatile challenge; it requires a co-ordinated, cross-government approach. This reality must be acknowledged.”

HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary and Chief Fire & Rescue Inspector Andy Cooke
Sir Andy Cooke (Kirsty O’Connor/PA)

He said communications staff had made sure accurate information and the consequences of getting involved in violent disorder were clearly and widely communicated.

The report found that the disorder was predictable, despite national assessments that said the risk of unrest was low.

“National police intelligence assessments didn’t correctly assess the risk and threat to public safety from a rising tide of disorder,” the report found.

“Grading the threat and risk of disorder as ‘low’ was wrong and influenced the timeliness of national mobilisation decisions.”

It said the lack of a police intelligence network dealing specifically with disorder is a problem, and called for a return to neighbourhood policing so officers are more aware of tensions in their area.

While dramatic events fuel greater use of social media sites, tech companies must also be responsible about public safety, Sir Andy told journalists.

“It is great for them, but they’ve got to have social responsibility as well.

“These companies have got to have responsibility, irrespective of whether they are led from China, led from America.”

Gavin Stephens
Gavin Stephens (Jordan Pettitt/PA)

He called for the communications watchdog to get beefed-up powers to take posts down more quickly, and said the Online Safety Act has “little or no bearing on the real-time effects of online content during instances of rapidly evolving, widespread disorder”.

“Ofcom needs to have the proper capacity and capability to (get posts taken down) quickly if it’s going to be effective,” Sir Andy said.

“And in a national disorder issue like you saw, the speed of some of these posts that are going up makes it really difficult to get them down quickly.

“If you don’t get them down quickly, they spread virally.”

Laws around what is classed as inciting public disorder should also be tightened up so there are tougher consequences for those who knowingly post false information online, he said.

The chairwoman of the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners, Emily Spurrell, said: “It is extremely concerning that the inspectorate finds forces have failed to learn lessons following previous incidents of widespread violent disorder.

“Technology is transforming society, and it is vital the police service keeps up with that.

“If our police are to respond to the kind of trouble we saw last summer, forces must prioritise investing time, resources and in the technology to identify those who might incite, promote and organise disorder on our streets.

“They need to develop the capability to monitor online sources, recognising and acting on intelligence of potential violence.”

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

View of the Alphawave Semi logo is seen displayed on a smartphone screen

Alphawave agrees £1.8bn takeover by America’s Qualcomm

The TikTok logo displayed on a phone

TikTok creating more than 500 new British jobs as UK users top 30 million

Starmer visit to London Tech Week conference

Sir Keir Starmer vows to overcome sceptical public on ‘harnessing power’ of AI

A sign for the Post Office

More than £1 billion paid to those wronged by Horizon scandal, Government says

One in three employers believe AI will boost productivity

‘Significant challenges’ in use of AI within UK screen sector

Students use laptop computers to study in class

AI skills drive in schools to ‘put power in hands of next generation’ – Starmer

Australia will ban social media for under-16s.

Children could face 'two-hour social media limit' under new Government proposal

Peter Kyle

Minister says AI ‘does lie’ but defends Government amid copyright row

Ian Russell

Molly Russell’s father urges PM to act over online harms as ‘app cap’ considered

Rachel Reeves, left, wearing a lab coat and putting on some disposable gloves with Peter Kyle, both standing next to a microscope

Rachel Reeves to announce £86bn for science and technology in spending review

The Baden municipality of Schutterwald near Offenburg in Germany was ravaged by a plague of the ants in March

Foul-smelling ants that form supercolonies wreak havoc across Europe - with fears they could invade UK

Judges have warned against the use of deepfakes

Use of AI-generated fake cases in court could lead to sanctions, judges warn

People at NatWest cash points

NatWest fixes issues which left customers unable to use mobile app

Close up of The National Lottery Lotto sign

National Lottery group planning 36-hour outage for long delayed tech update

Amazon has promised to work harder to tackle fake reviews on its site following an investigation by the competition watchdog.

Amazon UK commits to working harder to tackle fake reviews

The photo shows a model of the lander 'Resilience' at the event venue, in Tokyo, Japan.

Latest moon landing attempt 'likely to have crashed', ispace confirms